It’s NOT about the money!

by trey on January 4, 2010

What is the goal of business? As one classically trained in American business, I can confidently quote to you the textbook answer:

The goal of business is to increase shareholder wealth.

While one might think “shareholder wealth” would be open to interpretation, I’ll put your mind at rest by letting you know the almost universal understanding of the term is MONEY.

This being the third installment of a review of Tom Asacker’s profound book A Little Less Conversation, and in keeping with my initial claim that Tom’s a fellow contrarian, I’ll start by making the bodacious claim that the goal of business is most certainly NOT to increase shareholder wealth!

My American friends are now having canniptions and thinking I’ve lost my mind. No doubt my college professors who instructed me to the attainment of a Bachelor’s in Corporate Finance and then those who graded all my papers leading to the attainment of my MBA, are rolling their eyes. Also no doubt, my European friends are saying, “Like, no duh, dude.”

I cannot summarize Tom Asacker on this point. I’ve read through his work several times and I just can’t come up with another way to say it, so I’ll quote him:

Listen, all I’m saying is that people are emotional, social creatures, so your organization should be strategically designed with that fact in mind. Business isn’t about numbers. It’s about people and culture. The numbers simply tell you how well you did understanding and appealing to that culture. The fundamental notion that customers are rational actors, who are simply trying to optimize their individual choices, is defunct. Value can no longer be reduced to a simple relationship between benefits and price (p. 49).

What to do about it? Tom says beautifully what I tried to say throughout the last year (what I said was social media gives us an opportunity to examine our presuppositions about the nature of reality):

People need to change how they think about their business challenges. In my view, they should think about their products, services, pricing, place of business, promotion and people as a means to an end. And that end is to give customers a happy now, show them a happy future, and enhance their sense of worth and belonging (p. 51).

What does this mean for marketers? Quite simply, while you most definitely SHOULD know your own economics, if you focus on your economics, you’ll miss your opportunity to succeed. Look at the money (the ROI even) as a TRAILING INDICATOR of how well you understand your business. The money isn’t your business; at best it’s a measure of how well you do your business. Focus on the business, which means focus on what you’re creating for your customers (what you’re creating in THEIR lives, not your product). Focus there, and chances are, the trailing indicator (money) will take care of itself.

Tom Asacker on Twitter

My radio interview with Tom Asacker for the Social Media Professor program.

Subscribe to the Social Media Professor podcasts

  • Trey Pennington
    Thank you Jamie. I'll join your shout out to Mark Schaefer; he's a true social media to real life friend. He came through town recently and made a point to treat me and Olivier Blanchard to lunch at the beautiful Lazy Goat in downtown Greenville. He's also a quite thoughtful blogger.

    "frou-frou" works. Tim Sanders would applaud you. He goes so far as to encourage business people to become "love cats." Since Love is the Killer App was a runaway best-seller, others must find merit in that worldview as well.

    "World-view" is probably key. World-view is a holistic outlook. It's not a strategy, not a tactic, not a program or even an objective, though it informs all of those things. I think you're right to put passion at the beginning of the sequence.

    Looking forward to seeing you "rock the world" in the way only you can. 

    Thank you for commenting. Seems comments are often more meaningful than blog posts, so, thank you especially for adding meaning here.
  • Jamie Lee
    First, I have to send a shout out thank you to Mark W Schaefer because it's through his blog that I discovered yours ... and I'm loving it!

    I am encouraged that people are becoming more open to the concept of building a business based on an authentic purpose vs a desire to make money. Although I agree with Mark that there has to be profit at the end of the Yellow Brick Road, I think that you create that profit not by focusing on the dollars and cents, but by focusing on your vision and purpose.Everything you do must be measured against that vision, that mission. You need to stay on course and in alignment with these guiding principles or risk diluting the power of your message.

    Although it sounds a bit cliche and more than a little "frou-frou" (especially in the land of B2B), driving a business from your heart will always have a profound impact on your success with that business. I don't care if you're a starving artist of the CEO of a paper clip company, there's no marketing expertise in the world that will take you as far as your own passion.

    Start with passion, follow-up with on-vision strategy, and execute with expertise and enthusiasm. That's the way to rock the world - no matter what business you're in.
  • Owen Greaves
    Hi Trey,

      WOW! There are many times I feel and sense this very thing, but I do a very bad job of articulating what I'm thinking, Tom appears to be a very observant individual. And you for reading & writing about this topic, it once again confirms how much more I have to learn.

      We tend to focus on our own situation(s) rather than our client's / customers. We then get stuck and stagnate in my humble opinion.

      Good work here Trey, keep on it!
  • Trey Pennington
    BTW, after I get done with Immanuel Kant, I do hope to come back to the conception of "happiness." Then again, once I actually understand Kant's view of happiness, it might not be worthwhile. 

    In economics, we had a term "utils." I think some of my econ profs may have suggested that the goal of business was to increase them. I'll have to check my notes.
  • Trey Pennington
    Happy canniption day.

    Yep, we must have money. No doubt about it. He who focuses on having money, though, will find himself poor. Notice I did not say we could make it without money. The very important point to glean here is where the focus is, or what the goal is. 

    Those who see their business goal as creating something their marketplace values will have money. Those who focus on creating money probably won't. 

    When it comes to money, I'm with Zig Ziglar: "Money isn't everything…there are stocks, and bonds, and real estate…I've had money and I haven't had money. It's far better to have it."

    No delusion here. Incredibly clear vision. Create value for customers; money will follow.
  • Bill Free
    "The money isn't your business; at best it's a measure of how well you do your business."

    Couldn't have said it better myself.
  • markwschaefer
    Yup. Having a canniption. Glad to follow orders.

    No company can sustain itself providing a "happy now and enhanced sense of well-being" unless doing so increases shareholder value. This sounds a lot like building a business plan on page views, Trey. I see the point about the importance of creating a customer experience, but please do not be deluded. There must be $$$ at the end of that Yellow Brick Road.  : )
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: